Now I’m on record in these pages saying that I’m not a big fan of the Dead’s Dylan covers. Visions of Johanna does not fall into the category of covers I don’t like. It was originally released on Dylan’s Blonde On Blonde album.
The Dead only played the song 8 times – twice in 1986 and six times in 1995. This is the fifth ever performance of the song and it’s quite impressive provided how rare it was. For all of the dirt piled on the Dead’s 1995 track record, I think that this is a solid contribution to the project and shows that diamonds could be found in the rough, even when Jerry was clearly declining.
The first thing I think of when listening to this cut is: wow, this is 1995? It can hear why Phil included this version on the Phil Zone album. Vince’s keys sound great here. I don’t know if he was actually playing an acoustic piano or if it was just a very good MIDI patch (if the latter it’s a very good one). Bobby’s got some crunchy distortion on his guitar that combats the clarity of the piano here, but it’s a mix of softness and light that works, providing just a touch of edginess to a sweet song. Have I mentioned that Jerry sounds very strong here vocally. Again for 1995 this is unexpected. A diamond in the rough indeed. It’s halfway through the song before Jerry takes a solo. It’s about as laid back as the rest of the song. Suffice it to say he’s not setting off any fireworks here, but at the same time the sparseness of his playing opens up more room for the other players, especially Vince. With so many lyrics there isn’t another instrumental passage. I haven’t listened to this in a LONG time and I’m impressed with this cut, especially for 1995.
Just a suggestion,but this version of Vision of Johanna,got me thinking..how about a week of some of the Dead’s best Dylan covers????
Tom, that’s a good idea, and I’ll put some thought into doing something like that for a theme week. I’m on the record as not being a big fan of the Dylan covers so if I can find a few that really strike me that could work. Thanks for the suggestion.
I would guess that Jerry’s voice sounds relatively good here in part because they started using teleprompters for some songs and I’m pretty sure this was one them. That probably added a little confidence to his singing.
Blair Jackson around this time wrote something along the lines that the band overall was playing great except, of course, for Garcia. Everyone knew he was struggling but many of us didn’t realize how serious it was, we just thought he’d get in shape and bounce back eventually.
At the Soldier Field show on 7-8-95 when Jerry got to the “Mona Lisa must have had the highway blues,” line he pumped his fist in the air and pretty much everyone I heard talk about that show mentioned that. It just shows how rare that kind of thing was from him. Most fans got really excited by it during the show but I kind of felt he did it in part to make up for the lack of a great guitar solo like he might have played a few years earlier. But maybe I was reading too much into it.
Love the Dylan covers, BTW.
Re: Dylan covers – This is a good example of the type I like. Something a bit more off the beaten path and not overplayed. Queen Jane was played a lot, but I actually like that one. Quinn the Eskimo is good. Baby Blue I don’t mind on occasion. Something She Belongs To Me is a treat. If I’m in the right mood I don’t mind Thin Man.
But Heaven’s door? Blech. Masterpiece? Master, please stop. Watchtower? I’ll pass. Memphis Blues? More like Memphis snooze. A version may crop up every so often that I don’t mind, but by and large these are skip songs for me.
ah, one of my suggestions from awhile back, brother lunchbox…
Thanks & Praises given ‘pon u…
man, where to start…
Red Pants & a Purple T-shirt…
that’s what our beloved lead guitarist was
fashioned in this most fantastic of evenings…
and there were many times when Jerry was quite
animated, smiling, getting involved in Weir’s
smartass stage banter by outsmartassing him!!!
(it’s after the SMOKIN’ Ramble on Rose in the
middle of set:1, it’s alltime stuff, must hear hilarity!!)
3.18.95 is a KILLER SHOW for many reasons…
this EPIC cover is one of the main ones…
& man, have i&i heard this version nearly 1000 times…
seriously…
it was used on EVERY gd mixed cd that got
produced in my ‘music lab’ for quite sometime…
& made for some “Killer Filler” many times as well…
[AWESOME quality sbds became available for this show
surprisingly/thankfully not long after it :~]
haven’t seen a sbd of the Unbroken Chain from 3.19.95 surface yet…
hmmmmmmmm…
whatta night THAT was, if only for that one life-altering moment…
3.18.95 was one of thee finest gd performances i&i was fortunate
to witness, outta 55 show (6.14.92 – 6.19.95) definitely top 5-7 for me…
i’m (only) 37…
anyways, Jerry was so into Visions this night, you could feel it
as he belted out each line with such inflection, such conviction…
such passion…
i&i was fortunate to be @ all 3 Oakland shows (2.24-2.26.95)
right before this Philly run, and although the Visions played
that run was great, as is 7.8.95, THIS is THEE one…
thanks again for choosing this one, lunchbox…
truly an amazing version of an amazing tune…
cheers, mate…
“Mona Lisa musta had those highway blues…
you could teeeeeeelllll (voice cracks, sooo awesome) by the way she smiles…
♤
ps, there is a KILLER UJB & Drumz>Space!>Jam!! also worth diggin on this nite…
Just thought I’d add a bit of trivia for any readers out there who like Steely Dan. In the song Dr. Wu, the lyric, “All night long, we would sing that stupid song, and every word, I knew was true,” is referring to Visions of Johanna.
Masterpiece is one of my all time favorite songs from any band, but to each his own I guess. There are several interesting Dylan covers among Jerry and Bob’s solo projects also (but pretty much anyone reading this already knows that).
y’all are haters…
dead fans…
not heads…
waaay too much negativity all the time here…
dissing tunes, starting often with something like ‘this tune usually bores me’ or comments of that ilk…
and really you clearly rush through your listening…
then write a halfassed ‘overview’ most times…
…you’re as guilty as your ‘followers’ haha…
like the guy who loves sharing his ancient reviews…
again mostly containing negativity…
yawn…
clearly my contributions have no place here…
enjoy ‘learning’ about the dead, young buck…
you gotta long long long long long long waaaaaaaaaaay…
way to go…
“you don’t mind Baby Blue”
laughable…
epic tune…
lot to learn, youngin…
signing off fo good…
I don’t think it’s necessary or “right” to love every single song an artist ever played. Conflating “negativity” and “criticism” is a dangerous exercise, which is what Ace seems to have done here. That’s his prerogative, but not how I view this site or those who have chosen to contribute to it. And I refuse to apologize for having an opinion. There are songs that generally bore me, but if it’s something I’ve picked to post here then clearly something jumped out at me about that specific version and oftentimes I gain a better appreciation for the song afterward. If anything, giving a good listen to a song I don’t generally like is a positive thing, not negative. That, to me, seems like a more honest approach than blanket praise. I’ve never claimed to be “Deader than thou” in these pages and I like to think I’ve been very receptive to the comments, contributions, and suggestions its contributors. I’ve actually delved into the 92-95 era more as a direct result of Ace’s suggestion to do so. As such I find his comment to be in bad form, but I guess that’s what the internet ends up being used for most of the time.
Ace, if you choose to no longer visit these pages, so be it. Feel free to post again if you change you mind. As long as civility is the rule of the day you’re certainly welcome here.
To all my other regular readers and contributors. Thanks for your interest and support. It’s greatly appreciated.
Opinions are what this is all about. How can a civil discussion be bad? There is no hate in being critical. We gotta learn to agree to disagree in so many ways in life. That so-called Ace character is the only guy I’ve ever known to threaten someone with physical violence because of a disagreement on the official GD site. The world needs WAY less of that. Lunchbox, I respect your diplomatic response but I won’t miss him for one second.
Well said, Lunchbox and Steven. We all love the Dead but it’s not hero worship.
One can only hope that the full moon on Friday the 13th was a contributing factor to that crazed post but, sadly, that’s probably not the case.
I find it rather humorous that this guy was putting down people on the dead site for being “old codgers” and now here he is referring to someone as a “young buck” and a “youngin’.”
This being, originally, a thread about a Dylan cover, and having mentioned a full moon, I can’t help but think of Phil singing, “And she steals your voice and leaves you howwwwling at the moon.”
This is the only tune on this compilation taken from the last year of Grateful Dead performances. Phil mentions in the liner notes that he finds the guitar solo “unutterably poignant”. The song begins less auspiciously than that, with Jerry struggling a bit with the singing and even some of the playing. But hear him growl out some of the lines like a fiery little Dylan, at times speaking a word or two rather than singing. He muffs a few here and there and frankly I am waiting for that guitar solo now. The drummers treat the groove like a moving target that the others must find. When the instrumental break happens, Garcia is surprisingly understated in his expression. I hear some interesting little chording that makes it unusual in some ways, but can’t say that I hear what Phil hears in it. The next verse is sung with a fun rise in the dynamic in its first half. The verse after that is much quieter and the band faithfully rides on whatever vibe Jerry puts forth with his voice and guitar. Listen for Vince Welnick adding tasty piano fills in these last parts. It is a long song, and it feels like a relief when it ends without disaster.
I was fortunate enough to see the GD debut of this song [3/19/86] and was on a real Dylan jag at the time. I was impressed that Jerry nailed the lyrics that night with no teleprompter in sight. This version is very sweet as well…”poignant” is an excellent descriptor. The next night we got the return of “Box of Rain”. The ol’ Space Ship in Hampton was very good to me…